Mister Eclectic (howeird) wrote,
Mister Eclectic

Scalia the misunderstood

People don't read past the headline or the 10-second sound byte. The media sensationalizes these. So I posted this on FB for all the knee-jerks who were pounding on Justice Scalia for suggesting that Section 5 of the Voting Rights Act was an outdated, "racial entitlement". It's outdated, but it's more discrimination against a handful of states who sucked in 1964.

Here's what I posted:
This is for all my friends who have been lambasting Justice Scalia for his recent remarks about the Voting Rights Act. First of all, he was *not* talking about the whole Act, he was talking about a specific pair of sections, 4 and 5, which make extra demands of certain states and counties.

He made the unfortunate choice of words calling it an "entitlement". That was stupid. But the law is narrow, it only protects cases of race discrimination, and it treats some parts of the country differently than others, when (IMHO) the Act should apply evenly to all places Americans vote.

From the DOJ web site: http://www.justice.gov/crt/about/vot/sec_5/about.php

"Section 5 freezes election practices or procedures in certain states until the new procedures have been subjected to review, either after an administrative review by the United States Attorney General, or after a lawsuit before the United States District Court for the District of Columbia. This means that voting changes in covered jurisdictions may not be used until that review has been obtained."

The states which the law singles out are:
Alabama, Alaska, Arizona, Georgia, Louisiana, Mississippi, South Carolina, Texas and Virginia. None of these has changed since 1975, many since 1965. The original list was drawn up as a result of incidents in 1964.

In California it targets Kings, Merced, Monterey and Yuba counties (The DOJ took Merced off the list last year)
In New York there is the Bronx, Brooklyn, and Manhattan.
5 counties in Florida, but not Dade.
Most of North Carolina
Two counties in South Dakota
Two townships in Michigan (Clyde & Buena Vista)
and 10 towns in New Hampshire.

It does not protect the elderly (a big one for Florida the last two Presidential elections) or gays, or people wearing skullcaps, turbans or other marks of their religion.

  • Lots of stuff delivered, Lots of stuff done

    Spook joined me for a minute or two just as I was getting out of bed, I was already late from playing on the tablet and listening to the Monday…

  • Hot day with strays

    Spook only joined me for a couple of minutes this morning, she decided to camp out in the dark of the bedroom closet. The usual breakfast, kinda…

  • Unhappy return of the day

    I sleep on my left side because on my back is not good for breathing and on my right makes my pacemaker jab and it's also where the windows are. I'm…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 1 comment