Mister Eclectic (howeird) wrote,
Mister Eclectic
howeird

Deep Thought

Over on scendan and cinchntouch's pages, there is some serious ranting soapboxing opinion thrashing philosophizing about When Good Artists Go Bad. I've posted a bit there, but want to bring it on here.

The question is, can we separate our opinion an artist from our opinion of his art? And should we? Do we refuse to buy beautiful books, paintings, whatever from an artist because the artist is repulsive, a criminal, or belongs to the KKK?

I have a two-part answer. If the artist is alive, and will profit from your buying his art, then don't buy it. Encourage others not to buy it. But if the artist is not alive, or will not profit from you buying his art (a second-hand book, or maybe he's donated the proceeds to charity) then go ahead.


The specific case which brought this up is Harlan Ellison groped a woman's breast at the WorldCon Hugo Awards ceremony last week. Lots of people are saying they will toss his books as a result of this despicable behavior. As far as I'm concerned, the woman who was assaulted needs to file charges, and the rest of us need to stop buying any more of his stuff. What you do with any of his stuff you already own doesn't really matter, since he's already pocketed the profits. I don't feel good about throwing away a good book, no mater how big an a-hole the author is/was. Book burning has severe bad vibes for me. I won't throw away my Poe volumes because he was a drug addict, or my Lewis Carrol because he was a pedophile. I will, however, throw away a book that sucks on its own, regardless of how pure the author.

What do you think?
Poll #810592 Burning Issue

Will you be getting rid of your Harlan Ellison books?

Yes
0(0.0%)
No
11(84.6%)
Maybe
0(0.0%)
Don't Have Any
2(15.4%)

Will you be buying any new Harlan Ellison books?

Yes
2(15.4%)
No
6(46.2%)
Maybe
4(30.8%)
Only if he sincerely apologizes
0(0.0%)
Yes, after he has served his jail term
1(7.7%)

In general, does an artist's behavior bear on your purchasing his/her work?

Yes
6(46.2%)
No
5(38.5%)
I don't know
1(7.7%)
None of the above
0(0.0%)
All of the above
1(7.7%)

If you were a famous author, how would you behave?

Badly
0(0.0%)
Angelically
0(0.0%)
Like myself
12(92.3%)
Like Harlan
0(0.0%)
I plead the 5th
1(7.7%)
Subscribe

  • Garbage Day

    Up at 8, fish tank was still very cloudy. I put in more clarifier chemicals, but that made things worse. All my small fish are dead, during the day…

  • Score!

    After breakfast I got in the car and punched in CVS, and it showed me one not too far which I had never been to. Turns out the trip there got me a…

  • Unplugged

    Breakfast was a banana and half the bowl of watermelon. Then I took that bowl, the cantaloupe bowl and honeydew bowls and the little container of…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 8 comments